About This Location
Dating to the 1830s, this historic property began as a cave carved from limestone by Cornish miners. The restaurant and inn is considered the most haunted eatery in Wisconsin.
👻
The Ghost Story
The spirit of William Caffee, hanged for murder nearby in 1842, is blamed for the paranormal activity. Rattling doorknobs, disembodied voices, and full apparitions have been reported for over 180 years. The Cornish miners who built the original cave brought beliefs in Piskies and Tommy Knockers, and some say those mine spirits never left either.